sweatshops alive and well

Comments

So called sweatshops are good.
They provide money and training for people who would never have had any hope of either. They offer a boost to the local economy enabling local entrepreneurs the chance to offer services and goods.
Those who work in foreign owned sweatshops get better pay and conditions than local factories. They want to work there to improve their lives.

They are not the end of development, but they are an important stepping stone up the ladder to a better future, especially for their children.
If their grandchildren were still working in the same conditions then there would be something wrong, but experience in east asia shows that given liberal policies then within a generation the standards of living rise enormously.

That said, the anti-sweatshop brigade (often led by domestic unions seeking to preserve their member's jobs at the expense of the poor) provide a good service in keeping the standards reasonable and pointing out when things do get very bad (as they sometimes do).
[this is good]
Unfortunately you're as optimistic as I am pessimistic on this.

Sweatshops move to wherever they can exploit labour, as soon as the progress you proclaim starts to look likely the sweatshops are gone - that comes with globalisation, leaving a trail of boom and bust in their wake, while the workers are left with a very specific manual skill that can't be re-used, the temporarily increased wages leave them even poorer than before as local prices will have increased.

Sweatshops are usually bad for the local economy - the specialist manual skills aren't useful in building a sustainable local economy (one hundred sewing machinists who can knock out cheap t-shirts sleeves, but not much else, many with work related injuries won't help a small town), they drain labour from long term local business, or from farming. Instead of having a product or skill valuable to the region or local area they will have nothing but injuries.


Exports and foreign investment *can* be good, but most sweatshops don't last long enough to leave any lasting benefit.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in